Latest news of the domain name industry

Recent Posts

YouPorn says ICANN not immune from .xxx antitrust

Kevin Murphy, June 9, 2012, 09:41:34 (UTC), Domain Policy

YouPorn owner Manwin Licensing has rejected ICANN’s claim to be immune from antitrust liability.

The company has told a California court that its lawsuit against ICANN and .xxx operator ICM Registry is little different from the landmark case Coalition For ICANN Transparency v Verisign.

Manwin sued ICANN and ICM last November, claiming the two illegally colluded to create a monopoly that, among other things, extorted defensive registration money from porn companies.

But ICANN has said in its attempts to have the case dismissed that the antitrust claims could not apply to it as, for one reason, it “does not engage in trade or commerce”.

Manwin’s oppositions to ICANN’s and ICM’s motions to dismiss rely heavily on the fact that the court allowed CFIT v Verisign, which challenged Verisign’s 2006 .com registry agreement, to go ahead.

Essentially, ICANN is trying to wriggle out of the suit on legal grounds at an early stage, but Manwin reckons there’s precedent for it to have to answer to antitrust claims.

You can read Manwin’s latest court filings here and here.

The case continues.

Tagged: , , , ,

Comments (1)

  1. It’s difficult for ICANN to claim they don’t engage in commerce, when they own registered trademarks such as:

    http://tarr.uspto.gov/servlet/tarr?regser=serial&entry=75584695

    which have a “first use in commerce” date.

Add Your Comment