Big .gdn registrar at risk
A registrar that exclusively sells .gdn domain names seems to have gone AWOL, and ICANN Compliance is on its case.
Dubai-based Intracom Middle East has been slapped with a breach notice alleging failures to operate a compliant RDAP server, publish the names of its officers, pay its ICANN fees, and escrow its registrant data.
Some of these breaches seem to be due to the fact that the company’s web site is missing in action, today returning NXDOMAIN errors, and has quite possibly been repeatedly hacked.
Archived versions of its site from last year show it was at various times a Polish risotto recipes splog, an Indian burger joint, and a manga cosplay porn site.
It’s Intracom’s second brush with Compliance. Three years ago the case was escalated to a three-month accreditation suspension for pretty much the same infractions.
Unlike most recent Compliance actions, which have been against registrars with essentially no domains under management, this times some domains are actually at risk — over 10,000 of them in fact.
Intracom specializes/d in selling .gdn domains for under a buck apiece. Apart from a few dozen registrations in a few other gTLDs, all of its 10,000 domains were in .gdn. It was once .gdn’s biggest registrar, though that’s no longer the case.
The company has been given to the end of the month to comply or risk termination.
ICANN “reaffirms its commitment to diversity and inclusion”
It’s not exactly a U-turn, but ICANN has issued a statement clarifying that it’s still committed to the values of “diversity and inclusion”, if perhaps not the words themselves.
CEO Kurt Lindqvist posted on the ICANN blog last night:
While some terminology may have changed, the values that guide our work have not. Our actions and commitments remain the same. We have not stepped back from, retreated from, or abandoned ICANN’s core values, or an environment where all voices are welcomed, respected, and valued.
The metadata summary of the post, which shows up in RSS feeds and such if not the visible components of the web page itself, reads: “ICANN reaffirms its commitment to diversity and inclusion amid recent updates to webpage language.”
There have been no changes to policy or ICANN programs like the Fellowship or NextGen, he wrote.
The post follows the revelation last Thursday that ICANN had expunged almost all references to “diversity” and “inclusion” from a page formerly called “Diversity at ICANN” and now called “Representation at ICANN”.
What Lindqvist’s clarification does not clarify, or even address, are the reasons why ICANN felt the need to suddenly and sharply distance itself from language it has been enthusiastically promoting for over a year.
But perhaps no explanation is necessary. Anyone paying a modicum of attention to US politics this year can’t have failed to notice that the abbreviation “DEI” — diversity, equity, inclusion — has become politically toxic and the target of attacks from the Trump administration and its loyal MAGA followers.
What we seem to be looking at here is the ICANN equivalent of the Department of Defense panickedly erasing the Enola Gay from its web site.
While ICANN’s structural ties to the US government have been pretty loose and minimal since the IANA transition in 2016, it really doesn’t need to find itself fighting off a Trump attempt to renationalize the root.
ICANN kills off diversity and inclusion
ICANN seems to have become the latest American organization to back away from commitments to “diversity” and “inclusion” in the wake of a universe now controlled by the whims of Donald Trump.
The Org has recently started removing references to the D-word from its web site, sloppily editing its diversity-related web pages, replacing it with the less politically loaded term “representation”.
The “Diversity at ICANN” page is now called the “Representation at ICANN” page, and ICANN’s stated commitments have been changed from:
ICANN is entrusted with ensuring the stability, resiliency, and interoperability of the Internet’s unique identifier systems in an open Internet, and was founded on the belief that it should reflect the diversity of the Internet community.
to:
ICANN is entrusted with ensuring the stability, resiliency, and interoperability of the Internet’s unique identifier systems Internet and was founded on the belief that it should represent the broad Internet community.
The words “inclusive” and “inclusion”, also from the now apparently toxic “DEI” abbreviation, also seem to be deemed inappropriate. ICANN has changed its web site language from:
To live up to this responsibility, ICANN is committed to promoting greater diversity and supporting broad, inclusive participation in its processes.
to the apparently hastily edited (random comma in original):
To live up to this responsibility, ICANN is committed to supporting broad, participation in its processes.
The page no longer contains links to ICANN’s Diversity & Inclusion Toolkit, a set of educational materials designed to tell people that asking other community members where they come from means they’re a racist.
Also gone is the link to an ICANN Learn course on “Unconscious Bias”, which teaches you that not all nurses are female and not all CEOs are white men and apparently ICANN has money to burn.
While ICANN previously said it offers its staff “Diversity & Inclusion Training”, it now says it offers “Culture Training”.
All six references to “inclusion” present in the November 2024 archived page have been removed from today’s live page. All five uses of the word “inclusive” have also been deleted.
The November archive uses the word “diversity” 32 times and “diverse” twice. On the live page, those counts are down to two (where the word was used to refer to a named group or report), and none, respectively.
The link to “Diversity at ICANN” in the web site’s site-wide footer has also been removed.
Some of the edits are incredibly sloppy. The old page had a bullet point that read:
Community-wide surveys on Age Diversity and Participation and Gender Diversity and Participation
The findings offer insights into perceptions of gender and age diversity in the community, potential and perceived barriers to participation, and the community’s support for initiatives to enhance age and gender diversity.
But that now reads:
Community-wide surveys and
The findings offer insights into perceptions of gender and age in the community, potential and perceived barriers to participation, and the community’s support for initiatives to enhance understanding.
ICANN’s backtracking from earlier virtue signalling comes at a point in history when corporate America is steering away from DEI initiatives lest they incur the wrath of US President Donald Trump.
The question is: is this all just cosmetic, or will it affect ICANN policy?
The Org is currently considering changes to its Community Anti-Harassment Policy that would change the boundaries of what is considered acceptable behavior at ICANN meetings.
The proposed changes would either, depending on your point of view, a) make life more comfortable for people with protected characteristics, or b) make it easier to get cancelled for a cultural faux pas.
It’s been a few months since the public comments closed on the policy changes, so ICANN board action shouldn’t be far off. Will the Org’s retreat from DEI have an impact on its decision?
Kaufmann picked for ICANN board
Christian Kaufmann from Akamai has been reselected to represent the Address Supporting Organization on ICANN’s board of directors.
He’s the incumbent in Seat 10, having first been picked by the ASO in 2022, but he faced competition this time from Australian Karl Kloppenborg of Reset Data.
Kaufmann’s current term ends at ICANN 84 in October, but will be immediately extended for another three years.
Conflicted? STFU under new ICANN rules
ICANN community members who refuse to disclose their conflicts of interest should keep their mouths shut during public meetings, according to a proposed new code of conduct now open for comment.
An updated Community Participant Code of Conduct Concerning SOIs was published this week, following an initial public comment period late last year, which saw some community members ask for more clarity on what the rules mean in practice.
A key change states that people who won’t disclose their potential conflicts shouldn’t even get up to the mic to express an opinion in public, even when they’re not directly participating in policy-making.
“When disclosure cannot be made, the participant must not participate in ICANN processes or make interventions at ICANN sessions on that issue,” the new draft states (changes in bold).
The change might lead to some community members staying in their seats or keeping their microphones muted during discussions at public ICANN meetings.
The policy is intended to improve the perceived legitimacy of ICANN’s processes and policies by forcing community volunteers to publish a statement of interest (SOI) naming who’s paying their wages.
The proposal has largely been championed by registries, registrars and governments, and opposed by lawyers in private practice, some of whom think they shouldn’t, or ethically can’t, name their clients.
The argument goes that if somebody is being paid by a company that wants to torpedo or delay the new gTLD program, or is working on a patent covering RDAP, you’d want to know if they were working on policies covering new gTLDs or RDAP.
The counter-argument goes that if an attorney is working on new gTLD policy on behalf of Coca-Cola, putting that information in an SOI would tip off Pepsi that a .coke gTLD application is in the works.
The updated policy draft clarifies what SOIs must disclose — it doesn’t just cover employers or clients — and provides lengthy guidance on specific scenarios where disclosures must be made.
The types of interests that should be disclosed are broad, and cover a variety of influences and relationships, both monetary and nonmonetary. These could include: familial relationships; employment relationships; agreements to represent a specific person, entity or group of entities; vendor or contracting relationships; stock/equity ownership (other than de minimis ownership); and all similar types of influences and relationships that impact the discloser’s participation within ICANN. Interests can be general or they can be issue-specific.
Working group chairs would get the right (though not, it seems, the obligation) to temporarily kick anyone found to be in violation of the rules. Complaints could also be escalated to the Ombuds, but she’s not getting any extra enforcement powers.
Lawyers have had their objections to the policy roundly rejected. The guidelines now state:
When an attorney is engaged to participate in ICANN on behalf of a client, while that attorney holds specific duties to their client, those duties do not override the need for others participating within ICANN to understand what other interests are advocating and participating within ICANN processes… when that attorney starts participating within processes, such as participating in mailing lists, making public comments, joining working groups, etc., on behalf of that client, the client’s and attorney’s obligations to the broader ICANN community emerge
The updated policy clarifies that governments enjoy some immunity — they don’t have to disclose who lobbied them on a particular issue they’re engaged with — with ICANN assuming their nations’ own transparency laws will cover that type of thing.
For the domain industry, volunteers will have to disclose all the roles their employer has. Nominet, for example, would have to disclose that it’s a ccTLD registry, a contracted gTLD registry, and a back-end registry services provider.
The policy now also provides guidance for trade groups, academics and IP owners.
The draft is now open for public comment until June 30. It’s possibly the last chance you’ll get to file a comment without disclosing your interests.
.hot is for hookers? Amazon’s first premium regs revealed
Amazon Registry made three new gTLDs available to non-trademark-holders on Monday, and so far a handful registrants have taken up the offer of premium Early Access Period pricing.
The five-day EAPs for .free, .hot and .spot see prices start high and decrease each day until May 17, when they’ll settle at standard general availability pricing.
While the wholesale prices have not been published by Amazon, the registrar 101domain was retailing them for $6,299 on day one, $3,299 on day two, $1,399 on day three, $799 on day four, and $199 on day five.
GA pricing for .hot at 101domain will be $59.99, while .free will be $44.99 and .spot will be $29.99.
The early adopter(s) in .hot seem to be viewing it as a sex-related TLD along the lines of .xxx, .sex or .sexy. All the day-one registrations (in multiple languages) look set to be used for escort services.
The domains that popped up for the first time in the May 13 zone files were:
be.free
bible.free
sql.freeacompanhantes.hot
escort.hot
escorts.hot
incontri.hot
prepagos.hot
trans.hothigh.spot
hub.spot
The only new domain in the May 14 zones appears to be live.free. They’re not exactly flying off the shelves so far.
Because the zone files are generated at midnight UTC and Amazon’s EAP daily price-increase cut-off is 1259 UTC, it’s not possible to say for sure how much each registrant paid for their domain names.
Gname adds another 200 registrars
Singaporean drop-catching registrar Gname has added another 200 shell registrars to its collection, bringing its total to over 500.
The 200 companies are named Gname 301 Inc through Gname 500 Inc. More accreditations means more connections to gTLD registries and a better chance to catch expired domains when they are deleted.
Gname last boosted its portfolio of shells in December 2023, when it doubled its number from 150 to 300.
The latest accreditations will have cost $700,000 in up-front application fees and will add an extra $800,000 to Gname’s costs due to ICANN’s $4,000 flat annual accreditation fee.
This of course has a positive effect on ICANN’s finances. Its fiscal 2025 budget predicted 40 new registrars, and even its high estimate was only for an increase of 57.
It had only accredited 24 new registrars in this fiscal year before Gname’s move.
An extra $1.2 million it wasn’t expecting is almost enough to cover its community volunteers’ hotels bill for a whole year.
Gname’s main accreditation had almost five million domains under management, making it the ninth-largest accreditation of the now over 3,000 on ICANN’s books.
New Pope’s .com domain was registered the day Francis died
A domainer snapped up the .com matching the new Pope’s name on the day the last Pope died.
Cardinal Robert Prevost was elected this evening and took the name Pope Leo XIV.
PopeLeoXIV.com was registered on the afternoon of April 21, a few hours after the news of Pope Francis’ death was announced and after I tweeted on Twitter:
Pope's dead. Let the domain speculation begin.
— Kevin Murphy (@DomainIncite) April 21, 2025
The name was highlighted by DomainGang the following day as a likely candidate for the next Pope’s name. But by then of course the domain had already been registered.
It’s currently parked, with no BIN price listed.
PopeLeo.com has been registered since 2002. LeoXIV.com was registered in 2005, on the day Pope John Paul II died.
Two deadbeat registrars get their ICANN marching orders
ICANN has terminated the registrar accreditation agreements of two Chinese companies, which appear to be under common ownership, because they didn’t pay their bills.
EJEE Group Beijing and VIP Internet Industry are both losing their contracts, effective later this month. Both have common contact details, apparently run by the same person who had another registrar terminated in 2017.
EJEE does its business at category-killer domain domain.cn, though the registration storefront appears to be broken. VIP Internet’s web site appears to be down entirely.
While both companies have sold thousands of domains in their time, both have had just one or two gTLD domains under management for the last 12 months, according to my records. No registrants will be affected, in other words.
ICANN seems to have been chasing the registrars for their overdue fees since March 2023, over two years ago, according to the termination notices.
DotMusic has sold a lot of names, but not many are turned on
DotMusic, the company that started selling .music domains seven months ago, has had a relatively successful launch, but one in four domains sold have not yet gone live.
The latest registry transaction reports show that there were just over 30,000 registered .music domains at the end of January. Registry CEO Constantine Roussos tells us it’s over 31,000 today.
“We have more registrations than any community TLD and it is not even close,” Roussos said.
It’s certainly true that .music is already the largest generic-term Spec 12 Community gTLD from the 2012 application round.
But while 31,000 in six months is a good start for a 2012-round gTLD, there are currently only about 7,500 domains in the .music zone file, showing that about three quarters of names have not been activated.
It’s not the lowest unactivated domains rate in gTLDs — only about 15% of .xxx’s registered names are in its zone file, for example — but it’s pretty low. The similarly-sized .baby has about 84% utilization.
A low utilization rate usually means a high proportion of defensive registrations — registrants have no intention of ever using their domains but want to keep them out of the hands of others — but something different might be going on here.
As a Community gTLD, .music has extra hoops to jump through before registrants can activate their domains.
They have to have their identity and nexus to the music industry verified and obtain a special code called a Music ID from the registry, which can also be used for future registrations.
Roussos said that “the majority of the registrants have never owned a domain name before, which is great news for us”. He added: “My other guess is that most just wait until they are ready to use the domain to get verified”.
He said that many registrants are choosing to take advantage of a feature called SmartPage, which gives bands a template-driven profile page containing basic information and links to their socials and such.
Recent Comments