Latest news of the domain name industry

Recent Posts

ICANN closes .xxx forum after 14,000 comments

Kevin Murphy, May 13, 2010, 17:53:16 (UTC), Domain Policy

ICANN has finally shut down the latest public comment period on the proposed .xxx TLD, and now faces the task of finding the few dozen grains of wheat in about 14,000 pieces of chaff.

It’s general counsel John Jeffrey’s task to provide the round-up on this, possibly record-breaking, public comment period, although I understand ICM Registry may also provide its own, alternative, summary document.

I had a quick chat with Jeffrey yesterday. He told me comments were kept open beyond the advertized Monday shutdown because ICANN staffers are allowed to use their discretion when forums are seeing a lot of activity.

He also noted that the comment period was not a referendum on the merits of .xxx; ICANN had solicited feedback on a specific set of process options on how to handle .xxx.

It’s my impression that the 10,000+ identical form emails from the American Family Association may, rightly, wind up being considered as a single comment.

Tagged: , , , ,

Comments (5)

  1. Michele says:

    From what I’ve been able to gather closing a comment period is anything but automated. Pretty much every comment period I’ve seen has closed late 🙂

  2. […] ICM jumps that hurdle, the contract will be published for public comment (fun fun fun) for three weeks to a month, before returning to the board for a vote on […]

  3. […] has had to endure since it first filed its TLD application, and most of them have been marked by voluminous outcries orchestrated by US-based religious […]

Add Your Comment