Latest news of the domain name industry

Recent Posts

ICANN threatens to shut down .jobs

Kevin Murphy, February 28, 2011, 12:18:49 (UTC), Domain Registries

In an unprecedented move, ICANN has threatened to cancel a top-level domain registry operator’s contract.

Employ Media, the .jobs registry, faces losing its TLD if it does not shut down Universe.jobs, the controversial jobs board operated by its partner, the DirectEmployers Association.

In a letter to the company (pdf), ICANN general counsel John Jeffrey wrote:

By not establishing any meaningful restrictions on who may register second level registrations in the .JOBS TLD, Employ Media put in operation a TLD where anyone can register names, thus defeating the purpose for which the sponsored TLD came into existence.

We are calling on Employ Media to take immediate actions to implement restricted registration policies that support the purpose for which the .JOBS top-level domain was established, and to cancel registrations and/or disavow themselves of the benefits of any registrations that are owned by related parties, if any.

The move comes following a complaint filed by the so-called .JOBS Charter Compliance Coalition, made up of jobs board such as Monster.com and CollegeRecruiter.com.

They’re annoyed that the registry licensed 40,000 premium geographic and vocational .jobs domains to DirectEmployers for Universe.jobs, which has started to compete with them.

Jeffrey wrote:

It appears that Employ Media and SHRM, through the Direct Employers Association, intend to use the .JOBS TLD primarily to compete with other internet job boards. Such use is inconsistent with the purpose stated in the .JOBS Charter and represented to the ICANN community.

The deal came as a result of a change to the .jobs registry contract, made through ICANN’s Registry Services Evaluation Process, that allowed Employ Media to lift a rule that restricted registered domain names only to the names of companies.

What the RSEP didn’t do was change the .jobs Charter, which restricts “who” may register .jobs domains. Yet, weirdly, the Charter is partly the basis for ICANN’s threat.

Jeffrey refers to the Charter restrictions, which are easily circumvented, as “specious” and “do not serve the international human resource management community”.

This is the Charter that ICANN approved back in 2005, and which hasn’t changed since, remember.

To come back into compliance, ICANN wants Employ Media to shut down Universe.jobs and get back to selling company-name registrations.

I think it’s likely Employ Media will appeal, possibly by taking the case to arbitration, as its contract allows.

Tagged: , , , , , , ,

Comments (12)

  1. Thank you for bringing this attempt to unlawfully expand the Dot Jobs charter to the attention of your readers.

    Your speculation that Employ Media will likely appear could be proven correct, but I wonder whether SHRM will exert pressure on Employ Media not to pursue this any further. This mess has to be embarrassing to SHRM, especially given the written reprimand it received in today’s letter from ICANN’s general counsel.

  2. […] Then came the .jobs kerfluffle and like a wise little ostrich I kept my nose out of it. But the same question kept popping into my mind. If you can search and buy anything and slice and dice your search results for news, images, by time posted, blogs, weather, travel, RECIPES for crying out loud, why not jobs? […]

  3. […] claims the registry is breaking its Charter commitments to the human resources industry by allocating tens of thousands of .jobs domain names to the […]

  4. […] had threatened to terminate the .jobs registry agreement – which I believe is pretty much the only option available to it in […]

  5. […] The organization wants the ICC to rule that it “may, but is not required to, terminate the Registry Agreement with Employ Media”, as it has already threatened. […]

  6. […] The organization wants the ICC to rule that it “may, but is not required to, terminate the Registry Agreement with Employ Media”, as it has already threatened. […]

  7. .jobs is a violation of U.S. anti-trust laws if one would look at it from this perspective. No one company, organzation or entity shall hold a monopoly in the United States of America.

    .JOBS is not appropriate where it remains to similar to USAJOBS. and should be forced to shut down or revert to its original state.

    Trying to force employers to purchase domains with.jobs extensions is wrong.

  8. […] you may recall from deep in the mists of time (actually, February last year) ICANN threatened to terminate Employ Media’s contract due to the controversial .Jobs Universe […]

  9. […] you may recall from deep in the mists of time (actually, February last year) ICANN threatened to terminate Employ Media’s contract due to the controversial .Jobs Universe […]

  10. […] earlier this week, ICANN seems to imply that it was wrong when it threatened in February 2011 to shut down .jobs for breaking the terms of its registry […]

Add Your Comment