Latest news of the domain name industry

Recent Posts

More on my Twitter.sucks reg

Kevin Murphy, December 21, 2015, 07:51:32 (UTC), Domain Registries

If you were reading on Friday, you’ll know that I brought about the registration of the domain twitter.sucks and took charge of a web site hosted at that address.
I hinted that there was a little more to the story, but couldn’t get into it.
The first part of the story is here.
What I didn’t mention was that twitter.sucks was in my This.sucks account for probably less than 10 minutes before I removed it.
I have no beef with Twitter and no particular desire to moderate a .sucks discussion forum.
After removing twitter.sucks from my account, I noticed that This.sucks again gave me the option to “register” a free .sucks domain.
So I experimentally “registered” thisdotsucks.sucks too.
Again, the domain started resolving, showed up in Whois, and the associated WordPress site went live within seconds.
At this point, I discovered that I had admin privileges for both twitter.sucks and thisdotsucks.sucks sites simultaneously.
Suspecting that I may have found a bug that would allow anyone to register an essentially unlimited number of free and potentially trademark-matching .sucks domains, I informed This.sucks of my findings in the interest of responsible bug disclosure and ended my blog post prematurely.
Late Friday, This.sucks spokesperson Phil Armstrong told me that it wasn’t a bug after all.
He said that the company allows one “do-over”. So if you register a name for free, then delete it, you get another one for free.
He also said that WordPress admin privileges for domains removed from user accounts expire after a period (I had admin rights for the twitter.sucks web site for roughly 48 hours after I deleted it from my account.)
Right now, the domain twitter.sucks still exists, registered to This.sucks as before, as does the associated web site. I have no idea if another user has taken over its administration or if it’s in some kind of limbo state.
All I know is that it’s nothing to do with me any more.


If you find this post or this blog useful or interestjng, please support Domain Incite, the independent source of news, analysis and opinion for the domain name industry and ICANN community.

Tagged: , , , , ,

Comments (3)

  1. Louse says:

    Interesting experiment. Aren’t you nervous of associating with a potential trademark domain?

    • Kevin Murphy says:

      Not particularly. I was never the registered name holder, and there was self-evidently never any bad-faith intent.
      UDRP panels have had mixed views about domains containing trademarks that are used for comment or criticism.
      The domain also appears to have been deleted now — during the add grace period, I believe — which is kinda what I expected to happen.

  2. Antoine CALLOCH says:

    Looks like domain names that have been canceled, such as twitter.sucks or sanofi.sucks, are no longer available for free “You are trying to register a premium site.” .
    Register domain names with this.sucks and instantly withdraw might be the solution for PI holders ?

Add Your Comment