Recent Posts
- Unstoppable offering free .nft names to Twitter users
- Fun name-spinner uses AI to suggest domains
- New gTLDs: the next round just got real
- Ferrari survives carmaker’s dot-brand bloodbath
- CentralNic reports strong 2022
- Google partners with UN on aids.day, womens.day and more
- Guy wants to be ICANN CEO and turn off 1.5 million Iranian domains
- ICANN kicks the can on .org price cap defeat
- No masks required at ICANN Cancun
- sex.com for sale, but it’s not a domain deal
- ICANN to be told to stop pussyfooting on new gTLDs
- New ICANN boss makes encouraging noises on new gTLDs
- Verisign loses prestige .gov contract to Cloudflare
- Wanted: a gTLD to ban
- Interview: Sandeep Ramchandani on 10 years of Radix and new gTLDs
- sex.xyz sells at $11,000 loss as premium renewal kicks in
- IRP panel tells ICANN to stop being so secretive, again
- Nominet blew six figures vanity-publishing ex-CEO’s book
- New gTLDs grow in China as .cn regs slide
- Domainers grumble as GoDaddy cranks up commission fees
- Namecheap says it won legal fight over .org price caps
- Identity Digital sees abuse up a bit in Q3
- UDRPs up in 2022, firm says
- More details on ICANN’s CEO handover
- Merry Christmas! Marby finally out as ICANN CEO
- ICANN loses another dot-brand, this one in use
- Abuse crackdown likely in next gTLD registrar contract
- ICANN expects to approve Whois Disclosure System next month
- .music gets its first live web site
- CentralNic buys a bunch of web sites for $5.2 million
- Industry outlook gloomy for next year, predicts ICANN
- Content police? ICANN mulls bylaws change
- ICANN bloat to continue as new gTLD program begins
- ICANN spunks a year, $9 million, on new gTLD plans destined for trashcan
- Crawford QUITS as CentralNic CEO
- Drop-catcher adds 100 more registrars after rapid growth
- Domain universe shrinks again: .com and .cn down, .au up
- New gTLD applications to cost about $250,000
- Macy’s scraps .macys gTLD
- Elon Musk chaos credited with surge in .social regs
- InternetNZ says sorry for “institutional racism”
- Melbourne IT to relaunch, return to roots, after $3.4 million acquisition
- Registrars CAN charge for Whois, ICANN grudgingly admits
- New new gTLD registry in town as Rostam buys UNR
- Stop me if you’ve heard this…
- Verisign growth slows with post-Covid blues
- CentralNic gobbles up another registrar
- Blind auditions underway for ICANN’s supreme court
- Right-wing YouTube bought rumble.com from founder for $477,077
- You can’t appeal a UDRP appeal, ICANN Ombudsman says
- Unstoppable Domains stops over 116,000 domains as alt-root TLD goes dark
- CentralNic expects to blow past revenue estimates
- [Guest Post] Hey ICANN: Reporters are not the enemy
- Is ICANN toothless in the face of DNS abuse?
- ICANN to mull bulk registration ban
- .au adds 100,000 names in days after 2LD floodgates open
- Registry launches Ukrainian domains for Russian-occupied region
- DNSSEC claims another ccTLD victim
- Taliban seizing domains to silence journalists
- McCarthy wins Nominet director election
- Nominet “gaslighting” members over fees, candidate claims
- ICANN dodges bullet as American elected to ITU top job
- Identity Digital publishes treasure trove of abuse data
- Paraguay to chair the GAC
- Nominet may owe its members millions, top lawyer says
- ICANN approves ccTLD-killer policy
- .br tops five million names
- ICANN returning to Puerto Rico
- Ukrainians urged to “de-Russify” their domains
- .au passes four million names as 2LDs surge
- .com and .net are the drag factor on domain industry growth
- Nominet gets new CFO
- It’s ICANN versus the blockchain in Kuala Lumpur
- ICANN to “stand up” to Russia at the ITU
- Surprise new chair for ICANN announced
- PIR will launch .giving next month with unusual landrush rules
- Last-minute bombshell in Nominet election — it may be ILLEGAL
- ICANN finished year $24 million ahead but loses $29 million on the markets
- CentralNic picks up marketing firm for up to $19 million
- Whois Disclosure System to cost up to $3.3 million, run for one year
- ICANN director’s registry CEO job up for grabs
- MarkMonitor to join Newfold in $300 million deal
- New ICANN contracts chart the death throes of Whois
- Kiwi Farms domain lands at Epik
- CentralNic passes on abandoned dot-brand
- Cloudflare blocks anti-trans site for “emergency threat to human life”
- GoCompare makes a big bet on a new gTLD
- Epik replaces Monster with younger clone
- Alt-root .eth is getting very big, very fast
- ZADNA under fire over “heavy-handed” new rules
- Identity Digital to release 5,000 reserved names
- Millions of .cn domains disappear
- ICANN throws out prostitution complaint
- CentralNic revenue almost doubles
- Drug dealer sells blunt.com for $165,000
- Did a sexy Russian spy nerf the o.com auction?
- Cancelled misogynist Andrew Tate moves domain to (drumroll)… Epik!
- Google reveals launch dates for two new gTLDs
- Ducos a shoo-in for GNSO Council chair
- NameSilo reports revenue up 33%
- Adoption light with four weeks to .au’s 2LD deadline
- It’s hustings season at Nominet
- ICANN rushes mystery directors onto board in apparent bylaws breach
- ICANN staffing up for next new gTLD round
- Radix premium revenue hits $3.8 million in first half
- GoDaddy shutters Twitter accounts after MMX deal
- nickel.com sells for a hell of a lot more than a nickel
- German motoring club dot-brand crashes out
- Verisign to crack down on Chinese domains
- Whois Disclosure System likely over a year away
- Belgium slashes its ICANN funding in “mission creep” protest
- Diversity takes a hit as NomCom replaces two ICANN directors with newcomers
- RDNH loser files second appeal
- Group crowdfunding crypto to apply to ICANN for blockchain gTLD
- Buyer “phasing out” domain “bought for $2.2 million”
- ShortDot drops premium fees on millions of domains
- Tucows’ domains business stagnates again in Q2
- Malaysia relaxes travel restrictions ahead of ICANN 75
- GMO to sell Unstoppable’s crypto domains
- More rules, but cozier ICANN 75 expected
- India offers dollar regs to celebrate independence
- auDA updates on 2LD .au sales
- At $15 million, nfts.com becomes second-biggest domain sale ever
- Now Nokia scraps a dot-brand
- InternetNZ appoints new CEO
ICANN puts blockchain on the agenda for good
Kevin Murphy,
June 23, 2022, 15:57:44 (UTC),
Domain Tech
ICANN’s board of directors is apparently worried about the rise of blockchain-based alt-roots.
Its Board Technical Committee voted in May to make blockchain a permanent agenda item going forward, according to just-published minutes.
“After discussion, the Committee decided to have a standing topic on the agenda to address Blockchain Names,” the minutes read.
The minutes don’t record the content of the discussion, but the alt-root topic has been addressed at every one of the committee’s meetings since last July and resulted in the CTO’s office putting together a briefing paper I blogged about last month.
Blockchain alt-roots include the likes of ENS, Handshake and Unstoppable. They are likely to present legal challenges and interoperability problems when ICANN finally opens up the next round of new gTLDs in a couple years.
This is a positive step, in my opinion.
Blockchain domains are not going away.
ICANN is unlikely to regulate them. But collisions are inevitable. However, the scope of NCAP doesn’t cover them (yet).
Tom
The problem is not blockchain, the problem is alt roots that happen to be distributed via blockchain.
If what you say holds up, that those alt roots are not going away, that would be most unfortunate since this is pure and simple fragmentation. And that decreases the value of the net for all its global users, not only for those holding identifiers (either ICANN root or alt-roots)
Users who care about blockchain domains will figure out how to use them. Otherwise, most people will ignore them.
Fragmentation exists in every market and the businesses that survive are those that adapt. Another word for “fragmentation” is “competition.”
Should blockchain domains prove to offer more incentive to users than ICANN domains, that’s a problem for ICANN, not global users.
Competition is not fragmentation. Fragmentation would be McDonald’s and Burger King requiring cars of different sizes to buy at their drive-thru operations, so you would need to choose your car based on your favorite fast-food chain. Competition is all fast-food chains allowing all car drivers to buy food.
There are no blockchain domains, there are alt roots (a very old phenomena in the system) trying a different clothing to appeal to users that don’t realize how fragmentation should govern their decision-making process.
What security measures will Unstoppable Domains, provide for criminals using their Blockchain Domains to create decentralize sites containing Child Abuse & Animal Torture?
StoppableDomains are for wallet addresses, they don’t resolve to websites. However, your point is valid for blockchain naming systems that do resolve to websites, like Handshake…but it’s also a tired (but still valid) argument. Criminals are going to use whatever is available to peddle their disgusting wares.
To answer your question, there aren’t inherent security measures to block content in any protocol so you do what is already done now; report to whomever is managing a website/server/TLD and escalate to appropriate authorities.
Just had to fix Rubens typo…
“decreases the value of ICANN-based domains for all its global users…”
Not a typo at all, Tom. It’s a shot in the foot for all Internet applications when fragmentation occurs, regardless of which flavor of identifiers one is most invested in. Metcalfe’s law work both ways, and the only way to make each one to grow in value is to reduce fragmentation.