Second new gTLD contention set revealed

The first showdown between new gTLD application consultants D3 Global and Unstoppable Domains has emerged, with the announcement this week of a bid for a cartoons-themed gTLD by a D3 client.

D3 said in a press release it has partnered with outfits called Animecoin Foundation and Azuki to apply to ICANN for .anime, representing the Japanese art form, when the next application round opens a bit over a year from now.

Together, the two D3 partners provide a cryptocurrency designed to enable people to trade digital art NFTs, and the NFTs themselves.

But the expected .anime application is not the first to be publicly announced. Last June, Unstoppable said it’s planning to apply for .manga and .anime with a client called Kintsugi Global.

It’s the second likely contention set between publicly announced applicants. Freename.io and 3DNS have both separately announced bids for .chain, of course intended for blockchain-related usage.

The next application window is scheduled to open April 2026 or thereabouts. There are multiple ways contention sets can be resolved under the current rules, but the main one is expected to be an ICANN-managed auction.

No more Americans as Holland wins ICANN board seat

ICANN’s country-code registries have picked their next representative for the ICANN board of directors.

Byron Holland, CEO of Canadian ccTLD registry CIRA won the seat, which was vacated last September with the abrupt resignation of incumbent Katrina Sataki, who had already been reelected for a second term.

I believe Holland will join the board, after the formality of approval by ccNSO and the ICANN Empowered Community, immediately as Sataki’s replacement, rather that waiting for this year’s AGM as would usually be the case.

Holland comfortably beat Nick Wenban-Smith, general counsel of .uk registry Nominet, by 73 votes to 30 in a two-horse race described by one candidate as a disappointing choice between “two kind of middle-aged white guys and native English speakers”.

The election of a Canadian to replace a European as ccNSO representative means the ICANN board has topped out its quota of North Americans, which could have an impact on other election/selection processes.

ICANN’s bylaws state that each of the five geographic regions can have no more than five voting directors.

Directors Tripti Sinha, Sarah Deutsch and Miriam Sapiro all hail from North America. Term-limited Becky Burr, also American, is to be replaced later this year, but the shortlist of her replacement options are both also Americans.

This seems to mean that the Nominating Committee, charged this year with replacing term-limited European Maarten Botterman and renewing or replacing Sajid Rahman and Chris Chapman, both from Asia-Pacific, has had its field of candidates limited somewhat.

The Address Supporting Organization is also in election mode for its board seat this year, but neither of the candidates are North American.

Registries have started shutting down Whois

Nominet seems to have become the first major registry services provider to start to retire Whois across its portfolio, already cutting off service for about 70 top-level domains.

Queries over port 43 to most of Nominet’s former Whois servers are no longer returning responses, and their URLs have been removed from the respective TLDs’ records on the IANA web site.

The move follows the expiration last month of ICANN’s contractual requirements to provide Whois in all gTLDs. Now, registries must use the successor protocol RDAP instead, with Whois optional.

A Nominet spokesperson tells us the shut-off, which affects large dot-brand clients including Amazon, happened after consultation with ICANN and clients on January 29.

TLDs Nominet was supporting under ICANN’s Emergency Back-End Registry Operator program are also affected.

The registry spokesperson said that the gTLDs .broadway, .cymru, .gop, .pharmacy, and .wales are still offering Whois, due to an interoperability issue:

“The sole reason for the retention of these gTLD WHOIS services is for interoperability with the Brand Safety Alliance (BSA) service integration, which does not yet support RDAP,” she said.

The BSA is the GoDaddy-backed project that offers the multi-TLD GlobalBlock trademark-blocking service.

Nominet’s flagship .uk is also still offering Whois, because Nominet discovered that some of its registrars were still using it, rather than EPP, to do domain availability checks.

The fact that a GoDaddy service and some .uk registrars still don’t support RDAP, even after a years-long ICANN transition plan, is perhaps revelatory.

I’ll admit the only reason I noticed Nominet’s Whois coverage was patchy was that I’d neglected to update one of my scripts and it started failing. Apparently I was not alone.

While RDAP can be fairly simple to implement (if I can do it…), actually finding each registry’s RDAP server is a bit more complicated than under the Whois regime.

All gTLD registries were obliged to offer Whois at whois.nic.[tld], and IANA would publish the URLs on its web site, but RDAP URLs are not standardized.

It’s not super obvious, but it seems instead you have to head over to IANA’s “Bootstrap Service” and download a JSON file containing a list of TLDs and their associated base RDAP URLs.

ICANN wins IRP because complainant literally doesn’t exist

An Independent Review Process panel has thrown out a case filed by a failed new gTLD applicant because the applicant was found to have not existed for almost seven years.

A Bahrain-based company called GCCIX had applied to run .gcc, for Gulf Cooperation Council, in 2012. Its bid was rejected by ICANN the following year on the advice of the Governmental Advisory Committee because it had no affiliation with the actual GCC, a political grouping of nations in the Middle East.

GCCIX has been challenging the rejection ever since, filing an IRP against ICANN in 2021.

But it turns out GCCIX, which apparently had only one employee, has not legally existed in Bahrain since 2018, when it lost its corporate registration for reasons that still seem a mystery even to the IRP panelist.

This kinda scuppers the former company’s ability to do stuff like signing a contract to operate a top-level part of the internet’s infrastructure. Dismissing the case, the IRP panelist wrote:

The Tribunal determines that GCCIX’s status as company “deleted by law” precludes it from engaging in commercial activity under Bahrani law. Those commercial activities undoubtedly include entering into a Registry Agreement and providing the technical and other services required to operate a gTLD… GCCIX has not had the legal capacity to operate a gTLD since at least 2018 and has not revived its capacity despite having ample time to do so.

The question now is who has to pay for this debacle, which seems to involve somewhere between four and 12 years worth of legal fees and other costs. ICANN says it wants sanctions against GCCIX, too.

The panelist said that a decision on costs would have to be made by a full IRP panel, and it’s asked both parties to have a chat about whether they want one.

Could Musk’s DOGE kill off D3’s .doge?

The creation of the US Department of Government Efficiency raises the possibility of a government objection to .doge, a gTLD that D3 Global has announced it plans to apply for.

D3, a domain name consultancy that is promising to deliver gTLDs in next year’s application round that connect to identities currently only available on blockchains, has said it it working on a bid for .doge.

But that’s an exact match to DOGE, a not-quite “department” of the US government created by President Trump in the last few weeks and headed by megalomaniac billionaire troll Elon Musk.

DOGE is tasked with cutting government spending, waste and fraud, and the department’s devil-may-care modus operandi seems to spawn fresh controversy on an almost hourly basis.

In the D3 context, the word “doge” rather refers to a social media meme from well over a decade ago — a photo of a dog called Kabosu, now dead, used as the mascot of a cryptocurrency called Dogecoin.

D3’s partner on the bid is Own The Doge, a project of PleasrDAO that says it paid $4,240,000 in 2021 for the non-fungible token (NFT) of the original Kabosu photo.

Own The Doge then broke the NFT up into almost 17 billion pieces, which are traded like other digital assets. It also makes money selling Kabosu merch, licensing the image, and selling ownership of single pixels of the original image.

The silly governmental meaning and the silly crypto meaning are linked. Musk, a known fan of Dogecoin, seems to have first proposed DOGE as the name of the agency he proposed to lead as a kind of in-joke.

His first tweet on that topic came August 20 last year, a few weeks before the .doge bid was announced.

Given the timing, the exact-match spelling, and the crossover in the semantic Venn diagram, it seems a .doge gTLD application could present a pretty big target for a formal objection.

If the US decided to start throwing its weight around on ICANN’s Governmental Advisory Committee, which has substantial powers to scupper gTLD applications, it’s easy to see how it could horse-trade its way to getting a full consensus GAC objection.

But would a Musk-influenced Trump administration choose to object? Or could its mere existence actually prove beneficial to .doge’s future prospects?

We asked D3, and chief marketing officer Mark Trang told us:

While we’re not going to speculate on whether or not the Department of Government Efficiency will affect a future TLD like .doge, anything the current administration does to raise the visibility of domains, cryptocurrencies, and blockchains we view as a positive for our industry.

It almost certainly is far too early to speculate, but that’s never stopped me before.

Quite apart from the .doge issue, the Trump administration has yet to show its hand on how it will interact with internet governance in general and ICANN and the domain name industry in particular.

It looks today, over a year before the next new gTLD application window is scheduled to open, that this kind of thing is pretty far down the Trump administration’s priority list, if it’s even on the radar at all.

The relatively small National Telecommunications and Information Administration, which supplies the US with its civil service GAC representatives, doesn’t even have its politically appointed leadership yet.

The Heritage Foundation’s Project 2025, seen by some as Trump’s playbook for government reform, says nothing about ICANN or domain names in its NTIA section (pdf), and even gets the meaning of the A in the name wrong, calling it the “Agency”.

As for Musk, he’s known to be well across domain names as a concept, though he may be a .com fanboy. When he reacquired x.com from PayPal, before subsequently renaming Twitter around the domain, he said it was for sentimental reasons.

While it was pretty much an open secret that the pre-Musk Twitter planned to apply for a .twitter gTLD, the renaming to X of course means that it cannot be a dot-brand under ICANN rules banning single-character Latin TLDs.

But rules don’t seem to matter too much at this moment in history, when the US seems more than ready to dispose of decades-old conventions and use raw financial power to achieve its goals.

So, yeah, it’s pretty much too early to speculate about what .doge and the domain name universe looks like under the Trump/Musk administration, but it’s probably not too early to be worried, or maybe even a little afraid.

$2 million Christmas bonus for ICANN

The domain industry performed better than expected in the back half of last year — well, better at least than ICANN had predicted.

The Org today said it took in $2 million more in revenue than it expected in the second half of 2024 — ICANN’s fiscal first half — because the gTLD registries and registrars that primarily fund it processed more transactions than it had planned for.

Registry and registrar transaction fees — paid on registrations, renewals and transfers — were both a million bucks ahead of budget at $29 million and $20 million respectively

Its FY25 takings to the end of December totaled $74 million, ahead of its $72 million estimate but flat on its FY24 budget.

Operating costs were in-line with expectations and down on FY24 numbers due to fewer people having their flights and hotels paid for at ICANN 82 in Istanbul last October.

Another VW car dot-brand crashes out

Volkswagen’s patchy commitment to dot-brand gTLDs is in evidence again this week, as the company has told ICANN it no longer wishes to operate .bentley.

Bentley is one of VW’s luxury car brands, based in the UK. It’s exercised its option to unilaterally terminate its gTLD registry agreement, with no explanation given.

The gTLD had a single resolving domain, which redirected to a .com.

It’s the first dot-brand to terminate this year, thought the notice seems to have been filed with ICANN in December.

VW’s attitude to its original portfolio of dot-brands has been all over the place.

Its .volkswagen, which one might expect to be the flagship, was terminated four years ago, along with its Chinese version, but .seat and .audi each have thousands of active registrations.

Yeah, we got phished, ICANN admits after crypto hack

ICANN has confirmed that a phishing attack was responsible for the hacking of its Twitter account last night.

The Org placed this statement, which suggested that the attack may have been more sophisticated than you might have thought, on its home page earlier this evening:

On 11 February 2025, ICANN became aware of a successful phishing attack on our ICANN X [Twitter] account. We are investigating the root cause of the issue and working to resolve it as soon as possible. ICANN uses multi-factor authentication on all social media platforms and has confirmed that none of our other accounts have been impacted.

The hack saw ICANN’s Twitter account tweet several messages promoting a newly created memecoin cryptocurrency called $DNS, presumably to scam would-be investors out of money.

The compromise, which seemed to be timed to close of business in ICANN’s home in California, did not last long and the tweets were swiftly deleted.

Now ICANN seems to have confirmed that one of its staffers was phished to obtain @ICANN’s login credentials, but the fact that the account was protected by multi-factor authentication creates an additional wrinkle.

Twitter offers three MFA methods — codes delivered via SMS, a mobile authenticator app, or a hardware token.

In each case, logging in requires the user to have a physical device in their hand to create the secondary login credential. The victim would have had to provide this time-limited one-time password to the attacker too.

I hope the staffer who got suckered, presumably a member of the comms team, isn’t getting too much of a bollocking today, as these kinds of attacks are increasingly sophisticated and managing online life increasingly complex.

Just a day earlier, the well-known BBC political journalist Nick Robinson, who presents the popular Today show on Radio 4, got phished in what one assumes was a very similar way and for an identical purpose.

This BBC article goes into some detail about the attack on Robinson, including screenshots of the phishing email he fell for, and goes a way to explain how even somebody trained to avoid this kind of stuff can have a moment of vulnerability.

While few of Robinson’s one million Twitter followers could have seriously believed that Today had launched a memecoin, it’s more plausible that somebody familiar with crypto and somewhat aware of ICANN could have believed that ICANN would. The two areas of tech increasingly intersect nowadays.

When the attack proved successful, the bad guy must have thought all of her Christmases had come at once.

ICANN says it is going to post more information to its cybersecurity incident log as its investigation progresses.

If it turns out the phish was successful because somebody didn’t check the domain name of the link they were clicking on, it could be fascinating reading.

ICANN hacked to promote crypto scam

ICANN’s Twitter account appeared to be hacked briefly last night, and was used to promote what looks like a pump-and-dump cryptocurrency scam.

A series of tweets from the official @ICANN account plugged a memecoin named $DNS from around 0200 UTC today, just when ICANN’s California crew would have been clocking off for the day.

“2025: The Internet Gets Its Own Currency. @icann is redefining digital ownership with $DNS – the first memecoin to merge domain governance & Web3 culture,” one of the tweets read, according to a screen capture from domain lawyer John Berryhill.

ICYMI pic.twitter.com/f8R3AzaLaO

— John Berryhill (@Berryhillj) February 12, 2025

The posts linked to dnscoin.org, which at the time was a live web site promoting “$DNS. Own the Internet Again. ICANN’s decentralized memecoin for domain governance”, according to what little remains visible in Google’s index.

The domain, which had been registered for years, has already been deleted entirely. Not suspended. It’s just gone.

ICANN seems to have restored control over its Twitter account fairly quickly, but Berryhill’s caps show the scam tweets were viewed by at least a couple thousand of @ICANN’s 104,000 followers.

The apparent scam appears to be either a modern-day pump-and-dump scheme, where investors hype up a crypto coin only to cash out when its value peaks, or what crypto investors call a “rug pull”, which is more akin to straightforward theft.

Either way, it seems possible that some people may have lost some money, and ICANN’s not-great reputation for security has certainly suffered another embarrassing setback.

It seems likely that @ICANN either had a weak password, or somebody with access to the account got their device compromised in some way.

ICANN, no doubt sifting through the evidence this morning, has yet to publish an official statement.

Did Trump just create the world’s next ccTLD?

Could there be a .gz?

I’m sometimes happy that DI has such a narrow beat. Today, it means I don’t have to discuss the legal, political, moral or ethical implications of US President Donald Trump’s just-announced plan for Gaza.

At a press conference last night, Trump said he wants the Palestinians to leave Gaza, to be resettled elsewhere in the region, and for the US to “take over” the territory and have a “long-term ownership position” on it.

The details of Trump’s aspiration are not immediately clear. Is he talking about a military occupation? Annexation? Does he just want to build another golf course?

It’s almost certainly too early to speculate, so let’s speculate.

With Trump talking about US ownership of Gaza, it is not beyond the bounds of possibility that Gaza’s future, should his plan come to fruition, is as a US territory, or something very much like one.

Populated territories of any nation in general get their own ccTLD. Puerto Rico’s .pr and Guam’s .gu are two examples of US territories with their own ccTLDs.

The US annexation of Gaza would not necessarily even have to be legal under international law or recognized by America’s peers in the United Nations to create the possibility of a new ccTLD.

The path to the root involves a lot of buck-passing and at no point includes a qualitative evaluation of whether a territory is legal or otherwise deserving of recognition.

As you may know, ICANN’s IANA department is responsible for adding and removing ccTLDs from the DNS root, but it takes its cues from the International Organization for Standardization.

Under long-standing IANA convention known as ICP-1, any territory with a two-letter code on the ISO 3166-1 alpha-2 list qualifies for a ccTLD. If a registry can show technical nous and local support, it can claim the TLD.

But the ISO takes its cues in turn from the Statistics Division of the United Nations Secretariat, and its M49 standard, “Standard Country or Area Codes for Statistical Use”.

A territory appears on that list as a matter of “statistical convenience” for the UN, and does not imply that the UN or its member states recognize that territory politically.

Palestine itself was granted its ccTLD, .ps, a quarter-century ago, as “Occupied Palestinian Territory”, despite the legal status of the territory being disputed, because UN Stats and ISO decided to put it on their lists.

So Gaza could possibly get its own ccTLD if the US takes it over and splits it from the West Bank, even if it becomes a contested hell-hole where the luxury beachfront hotels are bombed to rubble faster than Trump can build them.

.gz is available, assuming Gaza is not renamed Trumpland or Disneyworld East or something.